卓越實證概述 Best Evidence in Brief

How do teachers with different expectations of their students teach differently?

Regardless of students’ actual achievement, teachers’ expectations of their class can make a difference because these may affect how they treat the class. A recently published article in Social Psychology of Education examined how teaching practices and classroom interactions differ between high- and low-expectation junior high school teachers in China.

A teacher expectation survey was first completed by 50 junior high school teachers to classify them with respect to their expectations of their class. Teachers who had a high level of expectation relative to the actual achievement were classified as high expectation teachers. Finally, the study randomly selected and approached 10 teachers, eight of whom agreed to participate in the class observation study. Thirty-two lessons by these teachers were observed and coded using a structured observation protocol that notes down the occurrence of teacher questioning, feedback, and classroom management every two minutes. The teaching practices and interaction patterns of high- and low-expectation teachers were compared.

The result showed that, in some aspects such as the amount of questioning, giving praise and criticism, there were no significant differences between high and low expectation teachers. However, high expectation teachers did stand out in the following features: 

  • High expectation teachers referred to students’ prior knowledge and learning experiences more frequently, and gave more orientation or focus statements, telling students about the learning activities that would take place.
  • High expectation teachers provided more feedback to the whole class.
  • When students answered correctly, high expectation teachers were more likely to question further or provide explanations.
  • When students answered incorrectly, high expectation teachers were more likely to encourage the students to try again.

The authors suggested that the result could help teachers understand how their expectations get communicated to students. They recommended that teachers form high and appropriate expectations for all students, with the aid of effective teaching strategies and a warm learning environment, to support all students to fulfill their potential.

 

Source: Wang, S., Rubie-Davies, C. M., & Meissel, K. (2019). Instructional practices and classroom interactions of high and low expectation teachers in China. Social Psychology of Education22(4), 841-866.

Leave a Comment

發表評論